In what would be a huge capability jump, the Indian Air Force (IAF) is
increasingly interested in procuring the American F-35 Lightning II for
its depleting fighter fleet. Business Standard learns the IAF top brass
is formally requesting for a classified briefing by the F-35’s prime
builder, Lockheed Martin, on the capabilities of the sophisticated,
fifth-generation fighter developed under the US Joint Strike Fighter
programme.
The US government has not formally offered the F-35 to
India. A classified briefing would require formal clearance from the US
Department of Defence (the Pentagon) and the State Department. The
grant of such a clearance would be an important first step towards
permitting the sale of F-35s to India.
It is learnt the IAF wants
to procure 126 of the variant called F-35A – the air force version of
the fighter that incorporates “conventional take-off and landing”, or
CTOL. Another variant, the F-35B, incorporating “short take-off and
vertical landing”, or (STOVL), has been developed for the US Marine
Corps. A third version, developed for the US Navy, incorporates
“catapult assisted take-off but arrested recovery (CATOBAR).
The
Indian Navy, which has never ruled out operating the F-35 off Indian
aircraft carriers, has received a briefing on the F-35 as far back as
2010, Lockheed Martin official Orville Prins told this correspondent.
However, at that stage, the F-35 was still grappling with serious
development challenges.
The F-35’s affordability is also
attractive for New Delhi. In contrast to the bare-bones price of $115
million for each Rafale fighter (with India-specific enhancements,
spares, logistics and weapons all extra), the F-35A cost customers $94.6
million last February. Lockheed Martin says it will reduce the cost to
$80 million by 2020.
A fifth-generation fighter is characterised
by a “stealth design”, making it far more difficult for radar to detect;
“supercruise”, or the ability to fly at supersonic speeds without
engaging engine afterburners; and highly networked avionics that detect
and engage enemy aircraft using a range of sensors and weapons across
the battle-space.
The only true fifth-generation fighters in
service are the US Air Force’s F-22 Raptor and the F-35 Lightning II.
China is developing two stealth fighters – the J-20 Chengdu and the J-31
Shenyang. Russia is developing its own fifth-generation fighter, the
PAK-FA, and has offered India a partnership role in developing the
PAK-FA into the eponymous Fifth Generation Fighter Aircraft (FGFA) for
the IAF. Negotiations on roles and costing are over, but the Indian
defence ministry is yet to accept.
The United Progressive
Alliance (UPA) defence minister, AK Antony, had ruled out buying the
F-35, stating that India would meet its short-term requirement of
fifth-generation fighters with the FGFA. For the IAF’s long-term needs,
the Defence R&D Organisation is developing the Advanced Medium
Combat Aircraft (AMCA).
Sources close to the Pentagon say India
would not be sold the F-35 as long as it is partnering Russia in the
FGFA co-development project. That is because Washington would guard
against the leakage of F-35 technology into the FGFA.
Senior
officers say the IAF is not enthused about the FGFA project. They point
out the F-35 is further advanced in development and has already entered
service with the USAF and six-seven air forces of American allies.
For
Lockheed Martin, an Indian request for the F-35 would create a dilemma.
The US company would rather have the IAF buy the F-16 Block 70, which
it has offered to build in India in partnership with Tata Advanced
Systems Ltd (TASL).
For Lockheed Martin, that would keep alive
the F-16 assembly line, which has long functioned from Fort Worth,
Texas, and has now moved temporarily to Greenville, South Carolina,
where it is building a $2.8 billion order from Bahrain for 19 F-16V
fighters.
The Fort Worth facility has been made over to building the F-35, of which over 3,000 are already on order.
Meanwhile,
the assembly line in India would build new F-16s for the IAF, as well
as for orders that Lockheed Martin expects from southeast Asian and
central European countries. It would also provide overhaul and upgrade
facilities for the estimated 3,000 F-16 fighters in service worldwide,
in some 25 air forces.
As this newspaper reported (December 16,
“Lockheed Martin says F-16 orders flowing in”) Lockheed Martin
calculates that an Indian line would benefit, in the medium term, from
new fighter orders worth $16 billion, and $6.5 billion in upgrading old
F-16s.
Simultaneously, American jobs would get a lease of life,
as F-16 suppliers in the US would continue feeding into the integration
line in India. At least 50 per cent of the F-16 by value would continue
to be made in America.
For all these reasons, Lockheed Martin is
painting the F-16 Block 70 sale to the IAF as a stepping stone to
eventually obtaining the F-35.
While the US has supplied the F-35
only to close allies, Washington insiders say India’s recent
designation as a Major Defence Partner (MDP), and a groundswell of
goodwill towards New Delhi, make conditions propitious for an Indian
request. An indicator is the recent permission granted for the sale to
India of the Sea Guardian unmanned aerial vehicle – so far sold only to
close allies.
In 2011, the influential US Senate Armed Services
Committee requested the Pentagon to study the feasibility of an F-35
sale to India. Senators John Cornyn (co-chair of the Senate India
Caucus) and Joseph Lieberman spearheaded the proposal.
But US
officials in Washington also complain about fatigue at New Delhi’s
tardiness in following up discussions with formal requests. The mood in
the Pentagon, say these officials, is: “Let New Delhi ask for the F-35.
Then we’ll take things forward.”
The defence ministry and the IAF have not responded to an emailed request for comments.
business-standard
